top of page

Global Economic Issues (Unit 3 Topic 2)

Trade creation versus trade diversion under free trade agreements

A free trade agreement can make a country better off, and often does — but not automatically. Jacob Viner showed in 1950 that one agreement produces a gain and a loss at the same time, and this tool lets you weigh them against each other.

​

The gain is created trade: the price falls, high-cost domestic production is replaced by imports, and consumers buy more. Both are genuine efficiency gains. The loss is diverted trade, when imports that used to come from the cheapest producer in the world start coming from the partner instead, simply because the partner is exempt from a tariff its rival still pays. The country pays more real resources for the same goods and loses the tariff revenue it collected.

​

How to use this interactive

​

Start on No agreement. One market, three possible suppliers: domestic producers, a non-member at $20, and the partner at $30. With a $20 tariff on everyone, imports come from the cheaper non-member at $40 landed, and the government collects $600.

​

Now switch to FTA signed. The partner enters duty free at $30, so imports switch source. Domestic output falls from 30 to 20 and consumption rises from 60 to 70 — the two purple triangles, worth $100 of trade creation. But the 30 units already imported now cost $30 each instead of $20, and the $600 of revenue has gone. That red rectangle is $300 of trade diversion. Net welfare falls by $200.

​

Then drag the tariff slider to $32 and watch the verdict flip: creation $484, diversion $60, welfare up $424.

​

That is the lesson worth taking. A high initial tariff means plenty of trade to create and little to divert; a low one means the reverse. Whether an agreement helps is a question about the numbers, not about principle.

bottom of page