top of page

QCE Economics External Assessment 2025

QUESTION 15: Sample Response


1 · The problem   Analysing · Problem
Rental housing in Australia is becoming less affordable. In Brisbane, average weekly rent rose from about $400 in 2018 to about $635 in 2024, an increase of about 59% in six years (Source 1). The problem mostly affects renters aged 25–44, who make up about half of all renter households, while the share aged 65 and over has risen from about 10% to 15% since 2008 (Source 3).


2 · The rental market   Analysing · Rental data
At the same time, Brisbane's vacancy rate fell from 3.7% in 2017 to 0.8% in 2024. Falling vacancies show that demand for rentals is outstripping supply, which is causing rents to rise. Supply is shrinking because owners are switching to short-term holiday accommodation, which earns a 40% premium (Source 4), while public housing has trended down for decades (Source 2).


3 · Who rents   Analysing · Housing occupancy
Renting is concentrated among the least wealthy. In the lowest wealth quintile, 95% of households rent, compared with only 5% in the highest quintile, where half own their home outright (Source 6). Rising rents therefore cut the disposable income and living standards of lower-wealth households most, while wealthier owners are largely shielded.


4 · Option 1: rent control   Evaluating · Economic ideas + Option 1
Rent control sets a price ceiling below the market rent. As my diagram shows, at Pc quantity supplied contracts to Qs while quantity demanded extends to Qd, creating a shortage. Similar countries have used such controls to keep housing cheaper (Source 5), but they reduce landlords' incentive to supply rentals: in one country, 30% of rent-controlled housing was withdrawn within four years and relet as holiday accommodation (Source 7). Sitting tenants gain in the short run, but in the long run there would be fewer, lower-quality rentals.


5 · Option 2: limit holiday nights   Evaluating · Option 2
Limiting holiday accommodation nights follows major cities overseas that cap entire-home bookings at 30–90 nights a year (Source 8). Holiday accommodation is about 3% of Australia's 11 million homes, about 330,000 dwellings (Source 4). If some of these return to long-term renting, the supply of rentals shifts right, lowering rents and raising vacancies. However, not all holiday homes would switch, especially in tourist areas, and owners would lose their 40% premium.


6 · Decision   Evaluating · Evaluation
Option 2 should do more to improve living standards. Rent control helps sitting tenants but shrinks supply, which worsens the shortage. Limiting holiday nights adds supply, which lowers rents, so renters' real disposable income rises. For renters, mostly lower-wealth households aged 25–44, this is a clear gain; holiday-home owners and the tourism industry lose some income, but the benefit is spread across far more households. However, rents may fall less in tourist areas, where fewer homes would switch.

bottom of page